- Free Consultation: (202) 448-5136 Tap Here To Call Us
It Is Time to Change Dc’s Contributory Negligence Law
District of Columbia tort law is governed by the legal doctrine of contributory negligence. Under comparative negligence, a plaintiff can be completely barred from recovering damages if the plaintiff was 1% at fault for causing his or her own injuries. Contributory negligence leads to unfair results, and it is time to change DC’s contributory negligence law.
Only four states (Maryland, Virginia, North Carolina and Alabama) and the District of Columbia still follow the outdated doctrine of “contributory negligence.”
Comparative negligence can deny judgment to an an injured party if that party contributed even slightly to the accident.
Contributory v. comparative negligence
The archaic and unfair rule of contributory negligence has been replaced by much fairer doctrine of “comparative negligence” in all other 44 states. Under comparative negligence, the negligence of the litigants are balanced and weighed. Comparative negligence determines percentages of blame between the plaintiff and defendant. Litigated cases are rarely solely the fault of a single individual. Comparative negligence recognizes that fact.
Pedestrians and bicyclists in Washington may be getting some relief from the harsh doctrine of contributory negligence. On April 21, 2016, a proposal to change the District’s long-standing contributory negligence law passed the D.C. Council’s judiciary committee by a 3-0 vote. The bill, the Motor Vehicle Collision Recovery Act, took more than a year for legislators to reach a compromise suitable to both supporters and opponents, including the insurance industry and trial attorneys.
The superiority of comparative negligence
Contributory negligence is not an economically efficient or fair method for determining compensation after crashes. It does not compensate injured parties who were not primarily responsible for their injuries. It allows the insurers of the primarily negligent party to avoid compensating the injured. Forty-five states — and the federal court system — have adopted comparative negligence as a basis for apportioning fault between parties in tort suits. It is time to align DC’s tort law with the rest of the country and change its contributory negligence law.
They Called. They're Glad They Did.
Brian Lee from Lee Legal was an amazing attorney to work with. He took his time, reviewed my documents and we discussed my situation thoroughly. He explained the process and my options as well as gave his recommendation. Not only did he assist, but he ensured that I knew this...
I was very nervous and scared about going through this process. But Brian was very knowledgeable and helped me through it. I was notified about any and all updates to my case and he was very responsive when I had questions regarding any concerns I had. Although a bit nerve...
Brian provided me with a very detailed analysis about my potential case after our first consultation. He promptly responded to all my complex questions, especially navigating student loans and some tax discussions. He is very professional and experienced at what he does, I would...
I've had the pleasure of working alongside Brian V. Lee for several years, and I can say without hesitation that he is one of the most knowledgeable bankruptcy attorneys in the DMV area. Brian's command of Chapter 7, 11, and 13 practice is exceptional, and his clients in the DC...
Brian has the amazing talent of taking complicated legal matters and distilling them down to seamless, frictionless resolutions. He is a phenomenal problem solver and a trusted advisor.
Brian is both warm and professional. He helped me navigate a financial issue that I had not been looking forward to working on and he made the entire experience non-stressful, receiving a lot of anxiety I had around the matter. He is straight forward and a fantastic problem...
I had the opportunity to work with Brian at a time when I was challenged by a professional setback and forced with the challenge of making some very difficult legal decisions. Additionally, I worked with him again as I was dealing with some financial issues pertaining to my...
Still several years from Public Service Student Loan Forgiveness and saddled with significant student loan payments in proportion to my income, I came to Lee Legal to explore the bankruptcy path. Through his counsel, Brian took the fear out of the process and helped me to...
